Lacroix Tarabay Légal
ENG
Montreal rap album launch sign reading “LANCEMENT DE DISQUE: NOUVEL ALBUM RAP MONTRÉAL” above a celebrating crowd

Sexual Relations: The Mistake-of-Age Defence

Criminal Law

Me Alexandre Lacroix

Alexandre Lacroix · November 18, 2026 · 7 min read

A person accused of a sexual offence against a minor under 16, who believed the complainant was old enough to legally consent to sexual activity, may be acquitted if it is shown at trial that they took « all reasonable steps » to ascertain the complainant’s age. In practice, this defence is presented through the accused’s own testimony, explaining why they mistakenly believed the complainant had reached the age of consent. In R. c. Simo, rendered on October 1, 2026, the Court of Québec acquitted an accused who raised this defence without having to testify. The prosecution’s evidence, on its own, raised a doubt. Me Alexandre Lacroix, criminal defence lawyer, explains.

The legal principle

In Canada, a person’s consent to sexual activity is valid once they reach 16 years of age. An accused therefore cannot rely on the consent of a victim under 16 when facing charges of sexual interference (s. 151 Cr.C.) or sexual assault (s. 271 Cr.C.), unless the accused is themselves of a similar age, within the thresholds set by law: a 14-year-old, for example, may consent to a relationship with a partner less than five years older (s. 150.1(2.1) Cr.C.).

Another defence is nonetheless available: an accused who sincerely believed their partner was 16 commits no offence if they took all reasonable steps, pursuant to section 150.1(4) of the Criminal Code:

« (4) It is not a defence to a charge under section 151 or 152, subsection 160(3) or 173(2), or section 271, 272 or 273 that the accused believed that the complainant was 16 years of age or more at the time the offence is alleged to have been committed unless the accused took all reasonable steps to ascertain the age of the complainant. »

A sincere but passive belief is therefore not enough: it must rest on concrete elements, most often obtained by questioning one’s sexual partner. This defence, which negates mens rea, thus has two components: a subjective one, the accused sincerely believing the complainant was at least 16, and an objective one, namely that the accused took the steps a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have taken to verify the partner’s age. These criteria are cumulative: the Crown need only disprove one of the two to defeat the defence.

A sincere belief as to the complainant’s age is not sufficient on its own. It must be accompanied by reasonable steps taken to verify that age.

Is the accused’s testimony optional?

Criminal defence lawyer in Montreal – law firm meeting room
An accused who chooses not to testify retains the presumption of innocence

An accused person cannot be compelled to testify at their trial. This right is protected by the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and the judge may draw no inference from it. That said, the mistake-of-age defence raises a particular difficulty for someone who does not wish to testify: who is better placed than the accused to testify about what they believed, and about the steps they took to learn their partner’s age?

Judge Galiatsatos puts the question bluntly:

[137] Reduced to its simplest expression, the question is this: how can the Court find that the accused sincerely believed the complainant was of age, without the accused telling us what he believed – and why? [Our translation]

Although the evidence supporting a defence need not necessarily come from the accused’s testimony, it most often does. It is true that it may also emerge from the facts of the case, from the testimony of prosecution witnesses or from any other evidence revealed at trial: it may, for example, take the form of an admission by the complainant herself that she lied about her age. The Court notes that this situation is exceptional:

[142] Moreover, while testifying is not an absolute legal requirement, the accused’s failure to testify could seriously compromise his ability to secure an acquittal with this defence. Like the judges in R. v. Silavi and R. v. Ross, the undersigned was unable to find a single example in the case law where a mistake-of-age defence succeeded on the merits without the accused testifying. The bar is therefore clearly high, without being insurmountable. [Our translation]

An accused who chooses not to testify retains the presumption of innocence. But for the mistake-of-age defence, the prosecution’s evidence must then contain, on its own, what the accused believed and why.

The facts of the Simo case

In R. c. Simo, 2026 QCCQ 4671, the accused, aged 19, faced several charges: sexual assault, sexual interference, participation in a group sexual assault, and forcible confinement. The events, which took place during the night of July 24 to 25, 2021, in a downtown Montreal hotel, involved some fifteen people attending the amateur filming of a rap music video.

The complainant, who was 15 years, 10 months and 20 days old, went there with a friend. When they met the accused, in his car, the two teenagers lied about their age. Each claimed to be 19, one adding that she was starting university in the fall. Over the course of the evening, they drank alcohol in the accused’s presence.

The Court first found that the Crown had not proven the complainant’s lack of consent beyond a reasonable doubt, owing to gaps in her testimony.

Turning to the mistake-of-age defence, Judge Galiatsatos restates the standard:

[288] The standard is demanding; the bar is high. The steps must be concrete and sincere, as opposed to superficial efforts made merely for form’s sake, as a way out to allow for eventual plausible deniability. [Our translation]

Listing some fifteen factors drawn from the case law, he then sets out the following table of criteria to be considered:

FactorWhat the court examines
Age differenceThe greater the gap, the more thorough the expected verification
Age stated by the complainantWas it asked? Was the answer clear or ambiguous?
Statement by a third partyDid a friend of the complainant confirm their age?
IdentificationWas ID requested?
Physical appearanceRarely sufficient on its own, as teenagers may try to look older
Social circleAge and appearance of the people accompanying the complainant
Alcohol, drugs, vapingConsumption in the accused’s presence, a nuanced factor since minors also have access to them
Education, residence, vehicleIndicators of maturity or independence known to the accused
Behaviour and apparent maturityAttitude, conversation, ease, without ever relying on the alleged sexual act itself
BracesA relevant, but not decisive, factor

The age-difference factor deserves particular attention. The Court draws on the teaching of the New Brunswick Court of Appeal in R.A.K.:

« … the difference in age may be taken into account in determining whether the steps taken were reasonable. Thus, almost without exception, the greater the age difference, the more thorough the verification should have been. An older or more worldly person would be expected to ask more questions than a young man like R.A.K. » (as cited at para. [295]) [Our translation of the French version quoted in Simo]

Finally, the Court specifies that asking someone’s age is generally a reasonable step, but that it will not always be sufficient to simply rely on the answer, « given the generally recognized motivation young people may have to lie about their age » (para. [291], our translation).

Asking about age is a good starting point, but the answer must be assessed in light of everything the accused could observe. The greater the age gap, the more the accused is expected to dig.

Since the two teenagers’ lies were told « without any ambiguity or hesitation » and nothing in the evidence made them inherently doubtful, the Court concluded that the steps taken by Simo were reasonable. It should be added that the context of the encounter, a late-night downtown video shoot where alcohol was served, and the complainant’s alcohol consumption were factors that contributed to this decision.

As for the age difference, the Court clearly distinguishes Simo’s situation from that of an older adult:

[318] Finally, Simo was himself 19 at the time of the interactions. The age difference was relatively minor. Unlike a 45-year-old accused, from whom heightened vigilance is expected, it can be inferred that a 19-year-old is used to socializing with people of roughly the same age as himself. [Our translation]

Nor did the Court disregard the evidence pointing the other way: the complainant wore braces and had mentioned that her mother did not want her working too far from home. Although these elements may have given Mr. Simo « pause for thought, » they are not necessarily inconsistent with the complainant’s stated age:

[323] Having considered the evidence as a whole, given the deliberate lie told by PL1 and PL2, their appearance, the context of the encounter and the other circumstances mentioned above, this is one of those cases where asking about age was sufficient verification on Simo’s part. [Our translation]

[325] A reasonable 19-year-old, in the same circumstances known to the accused, would legitimately have relied on the two girls’ answer as to their age. [Our translation]

The accused was acquitted on all counts. At the time of writing, the Crown’s appeal period has not expired.

A free information session with Me Alexandre Lacroix

Sexual offences against minors are among the most serious charges in the Criminal Code and carry, upon conviction, mandatory minimum prison sentences, registration as a sex offender and a criminal record with lasting consequences. The Simo judgment shows how much the outcome of these cases depends on a careful analysis of the disclosed evidence and on strategic decisions, including whether or not to testify. Me Alexandre Lacroix offers a free, no-obligation information session to analyze your case and assess the defences available to you.

The content of this post is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every situation is unique — consult a legal professional for advice tailored to your case.